Showing posts with label Art. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Art. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 23, 2023

AAUP Issues Report on Hamline University Islamic Art Controversy

 The Association of American University Professors Committee A on Academic Freedom and Tenure has released its report (full text) on the actions of Hamline University in refusing to renew the contract of a part-time art history professor who created a controversy when she presented two historical images of the Prophet Muhammad in an online class session. (See prior posting.) The AAUP Report concluded in part:

Professor Erika López Prater’s decision to display historical images of the Prophet Muhammad in a World Art class was not only justifiable and appropriate on both scholarly and pedagogical grounds; it was also protected by academic freedom. The Hamline administration was wrong to characterize this decision as “undeniably inconsiderate, disrespectful and Islamophobic.” Similarly, the university’s contention that care for students must “supersede” academic freedom reflected an inaccurate and harmful understanding of the nature of academic freedom in the classroom. The university has since disavowed both claims.

The Star Beacon discusses the report and the University's response to it.

Monday, January 21, 2019

Mobile Home Park Seeks To Require Resident To Remove Portrait of Virgin Mary

In Bradenton, Florida, a mobile home park, Bradenton Tropical Palms, has filed a demand for arbitration with the state's Division of Florida Condominiums, Timeshares and Mobile Homes in an attempt to require an 85-year old Catholic woman to remove a portrait of the Virgin Mary from the outside of her mobile home.  York Dispatch reports that the woman commissioned an artist to create the plywood painting which she installed to replace a window.  She contends that the park's enforcement attempt is anti-Catholic, and that she was targeted because of her religious beliefs. Management says she has failed to comply with park rules regarding her window replacement-- her filed paper work did not include a request for a change in appearance or design.

Wednesday, August 01, 2018

Museum Can Keep Biblical Paintings First Acquired By Nazis

In Saher v. Norton Simon Museum of Art at Pasadena, (9th Cir., July 30, 2018), the U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals in a lengthy opinion applied the Act of State Doctrine to reject the attempt by plaintiff to recover two oil paintings of Biblical characters taken by the Nazis from her father-in-law in a forced sale. At issue are Renaissance masterworks painted by Cranach the Elder— "Adam" and "Eve".  The Forward reports on the decision.

Monday, December 11, 2017

Fight Over Religious Artifacts Becomes Part of the Catalonian Independence Battle

An unanticipated development flowing from Spain's takeover of the Catalonian government is Spain's move to retrieve 44 religious artifacts housed in Catalonia’s Museum of Lleida. The Spanish government claims that nuns of a convent in Sijena illegally sold the rare artifacts to the Museum after the order moved to Barcelona. The Telegraph yesterday reported:
In 2015, after years of contradictory rulings and appeals, an Aragonese court found that the sales were illicit, and ordered the treasures returned. But Catalonia refused to comply, lodging an appeal which has yet to be ruled upon.
When that Catalan government was removed in November under Article 155 - which imposed direct rule in response to the illegal independence referendum - the Aragonese judge saw his chance, demanding that the return be approved by Spain's culture ministry.
The minister, Íñigo Méndez de Vigo, defended the sign-off, insisting it was not "adding to the fire" to comply with a court order.
It is expected that Spanish police will try to retrieve the artifacts today.

Thursday, November 09, 2017

Italian Artist Charged With Criminal Blasphemy

The art blog Hyperallergic this week reports that in Italy, the anonymous artist known as Hogre was arrested and charged with publicly insulting religion in violation of Sec. 403 (Criminal Blasphemy) of Italy's Criminal Code.  According to the blog's report:
Hogre was one of two artists who, on June 1 of this year, placed satirical posters in bus stop advertising spaces in the Italian capital. Hogre’s poster “Ecce homo erectus” depicts Jesus with a conspicuous erection, resting one hand on the head of a praying, kneeling child. This was a response to sexual abuse charges against Cardinal Pell, the third highest-ranking Vatican official.
If convicted, the artist could face a fine of €1000 to €5000.  Hyperallergic's blog post includes a photo of the offending poster.

Friday, November 18, 2016

Spanish Judge Clears Artist Who Used Stolen Consecrated Hosts

In Madrid, Spain, a trial court judge this week dismissed a suit which charges artist Abel Azcona with offending religious sentiments in violation of Spanish Penal Code Sec. 525.  The section prohibits publicly disparaging the dogmas, beliefs, rites or ceremonies of members of a religious confession. As reported by CNA:
Azcona stole more than 240 consecrated hosts from Masses celebrated in the cities of Madrid and Pamplona. He later took nude photos of himself arranging them on a floor to spell the word ‘pederasty.’ In November 2015, he displayed the photos as part of an art display in a city-owned exhibition hall available for public use. When that exposition was over, the would-be artist sold the consecrated hosts for more than $268,000....
The judge claimed Azcona made use of the hosts "discreetly, without his conduct being able to be characterized as disrespectful, offensive or irreverent." The exhibition of the artwork "does not constitute derision of the beliefs, rites or ceremonies of the Catholic Church nor is it an affront to those who profess or practice said beliefs," according to the judge.
 The Spanish Association of Christian Lawyers which filed the suit (see prior posting) says it will file an appeal.

Tuesday, June 10, 2014

9th Circuit: Suit To Claim Nazi Confiscated Artwork Can Proceed

In Von Saher v. Norton Simon Museum of Art at Pasadena, (9th Cir., June 6, 2014), the U.S. 9th Circuit Court of Appeals held in a 2-1 decision that the sole living heir of a Jewish family whose art collection was forcibly "purchased" for a fraction of its value by Nazi leader Herman Goring can proceed with a suit to recover two of the paintings presently in a California art museum. The majority held that the suit. brought under California law, is not in conflict with U.S. foreign policy. Judge Wardlaw dissented.